221 Prospect Street, Newmarket, ON L3Y 3T8
Location, Location, Location! Perfectly positioned on the slower-paced section of historic Prospect St, this home offers easy access in and out of the 9 car driveway while still enjoying one of Newmarket's most walkable locations. Just steps to picturesque Fairy Lake, vibrant Main Street, the Nokiidaa Trail, Riverwalk Commons, cafes, restaurants, boutique shopping, concerts, skating, farmers' markets, and year-round community events, you'll love leaving the car at home and embracing everything downtown Newmarket has to offer. Own a piece of Newmarket's history in this lovingly maintained home, where timeless character meets everyday comfort. Sunshine pours through oversized windows, highlighting the original hardwood floors and soaring 9-foot ceilings on the main level. The thoughtfully designed floor plan features a custom kitchen with a walkout to the backyard, making entertaining effortless, a formal dining room that opens to the living room with oversized pocket doors for more intimate gatherings, and a spacious, light-filled family room. Every window captures beautiful views of mature trees, lush gardens, and visiting songbirds, creating a sense of tranquility throughout. The generous room sizes and spacious bedrooms make the home feel both grand and welcoming. Outside, you'll find four charming porches-perfect for morning coffee, relaxing with a book, or enjoying the peaceful surroundings. The oversized lot is a private oasis featuring vibrant perennial gardens, a pear tree, mature trees for shade and privacy, and a cozy fire pit for evenings under the stars. A durable metal roof provides lasting peace of mind. This is more than just a beautiful home-it's an exceptional lifestyle in one of Newmarket's most sought-after locations, where small-town charm, nature, and community come together right outside your door.
Laundry
Tile Floor, Window
3.5 x 2
Upper
Living Room
Hardwood Floor, Bay Window, B/I Bookcase
6 x 4
Main
Family Room
Hardwood Floor, Bay Window, Overlooks Dining
5 x 4
Main
Bedroom 3
Hardwood Floor, Window, Closet
3.6 x 4
Upper
Dining Room
Hardwood Floor, Bay Window, Overlooks Family
3.75 x 4
Main
Kitchen
Hardwood Floor, Granite Counters, W/O To Deck
4.7 x 5.4
Main
Bedroom 2
Hardwood Floor, Window, Closet
4.2 x 4
Upper
Bathroom
4 Pc Bath, Window, Combined w/Laundry
4 x 2.5
Upper
Primary Bedroom
Hardwood Floor, Bay Window, Walk-In Closet(s)
5 x 4
Upper
Foyer
Tile Floor
2.7 x 2
Main
Interior features
Central Vacuum, Water Heater
Basement
Unfinished
Bathrooms
1 × 2-piece — Main, 1 × 4-piece — Second
Fireplace
No
Family room
Yes
Kitchens
1
Rooms (above / below grade)
7 above, 0 below
Approximate age
100+
Architectural style
2-Storey
Construction materials
Wood
Roof
Metal
Exterior features
Porch
Direction faces
East
Garage type
None
Garage spaces
0
Total parking spaces
9
Driveway parking
9
Parking features
Private
Lot size
87.25 x 185 ft
Cross street
Water/ Prospect
Directions
Water/ Prospect
Neighbourhood
Central Newmarket
Heating
Forced Air — Gas
Cooling
Central Air
Water
Sewer
Sewer
List price
$1,299,900
Original list price
Annual taxes
$5,597
Tax year
2026
Legal description
PT LT 2 E/S PROSPECT ST PL 85 NEWMARKET; PT LT 3 E/S PROSPECT ST PL 85 NEWMARKET; PT LT 4 E/S PROSPECT ST PL 85 NEWMARKET; PT LT 1 N/S LYDIA ST PL 85 NEWMARKET AS IN R689279 ; NEWMARKET
Inclusions
Exclusions
MLS #
N13605988
Status
Active
Transaction type
For Sale
Property type
Residential Freehold
Property sub type
Detached
Days on market
List date
Possession
TBD
Occupancy
Owner
Listing brokerage
RE/MAX HALLMARK CHAY REALTY
Co-listing brokerage
RE/MAX HALLMARK CHAY REALTY
$969,900
Median list price
33
Active listings
New in last 30 days
Median days on market
Estimated monthly payment
$6,232
Educational estimate only — actual payment depends on your lender, credit, and insurance requirements.
Sign in to see recent sold prices for homes like this one nearby.

$1,299,000
206 Richard Avenue, Newmarket, ON L3Y 4P7
RE/MAX IMPERIAL REALTY INC.

$1,258,000
206 Parkview Crescent, Newmarket, ON L3Y 2C8
CENTRAL HOME REALTY INC.

$1,350,000
98 Eagle Street, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1J4
COLDWELL BANKER THE REAL ESTATE CENTRE

$1,350,000
104 Eagle Street, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1J4
COLDWELL BANKER THE REAL ESTATE CENTRE

$1,199,000
158 Park Avenue, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1V1
SMART SOLD REALTY

$1,149,000
75 Beswick Drive, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1E8
TIMES REALTY GROUP INC.