412 Andrew Street, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1H4
A rare opportunity to acquire a property backing directly onto Fairy Lake in one of Central Newmarket's most established and desirable neighbourhoods. Surrounded by mature trees and just steps from the trails, parks, restaurants, cafés and shops of Historic Main Street, this exceptional setting offers a combination of nature, privacy and walkability that is difficult to replicate.The existing residence requires substantial renovation and presents an ideal opportunity for a builder, renovator or end user with vision. Completely reimagine the current home through an extensive renovation and addition, or demolish the dwelling and design a custom-built residence that takes full advantage of the remarkable setting.The property is being sold in "as is, where is" condition, without representations or warranties. Buyers are responsible for completing their own due diligence regarding the condition of the property and the feasibility of any renovation, addition, demolition or new construction.An extraordinary opportunity to create a one-of-a-kind home backing onto Fairy Lake, moments from the heart of downtown Newmarket.
Basement
Finished
Bathrooms
1 × 4-piece — Main, 1 × 2-piece — Basement
Fireplace
No
Family room
No
Kitchens
1
Rooms (above / below grade)
6 above, 0 below
Architectural style
1 1/2 Storey
Construction materials
Aluminum Siding
Foundation
Concrete
Roof
Asphalt Shingle
Direction faces
West
Garage type
None
Garage spaces
0
Total parking spaces
4
Driveway parking
4
Parking features
Mutual
Lot size
32.5 x 179.23 ft
Cross street
Main St & Eagle Street
Directions
Waze / Google Maps
Neighbourhood
Central Newmarket
Heating
Forced Air — Oil
Water
Sewer
Sewer
List price
$699,000
Original list price
Annual taxes
$4,431
Tax year
2025
Assessment year
2025
Legal description
PT LT 17 S/S ANDREW ST PL 85 NEWMARKET AS IN R315037 ; NEWMARKET
Inclusions
Exclusions
MLS #
N13639046
Status
Active
Transaction type
For Sale
Property type
Residential Freehold
Property sub type
Detached
Days on market
List date
Possession
30/60/90
Occupancy
Owner
Listing brokerage
RE/MAX REALTRON REALTY INC.
$998,880
Median list price
33
Active listings
New in last 30 days
Median days on market
Estimated monthly payment
$3,351
Educational estimate only — actual payment depends on your lender, credit, and insurance requirements.
Sign in to see recent sold prices for homes like this one nearby.

$688,888
388 Handley Crescent, Newmarket, ON L3Y 4T4
CENTURY 21 PERCY FULTON LTD.

$777,000
341 Cotter Street, Newmarket, ON L3Y 3X9
KELLER WILLIAMS REFERRED URBAN REALTY

$779,000
143 Thoms Crescent, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1C9
CENTURY 21 HERITAGE GROUP LTD.

$799,000
210 Currey Crescent, Newmarket, ON L3Y 5M9
REMAX YOUR COMMUNITY REALTY

$845,000
214 William Roe Boulevard, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1B5
BAY STREET GROUP INC.

$849,900
233 Thoms Crescent, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1C9
MAIN STREET REALTY LTD.