4421 5th Line, Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON L0G 1W0
Truly a one of a kind property - The Carswell House is a remarkable Georgian-style home with immense history and character. Built circa 1840's by one of Simcoe County's earliest residents, Andrew Carswell, this residence has been home to just 6 families over 180+ years. Historic character is preserved throughout, including original pine floors, original main floor windows, cross-and-bible doors with original box locks, a heated cobblestone kitchen floor, wood-burning fireplaces, restored woodwork, elegant masonry, and an original stone foundation. This grand home offers 3,530 sqft of above grade living space, plus a usable excavated basement with separate walk-up entrance. Upstairs, historic elegance continues with soaring 12 ft ceilings and restored wood trim. 3 spacious bedrooms plus a 4th loft bedroom feature individual natural gas heaters. The board-and-batten addition provides a mudroom with brand-new oak hardwood floors, main-floor laundry, and a recently renovated full bathroom. Recent updates include a durable metal roof, new UV water filtration system, whole home Generac standby generator, 400 amp electrical service, and more. Enjoy rare natural gas service in a rural setting! Set on an elevated ridge, enjoy spectacular southern views over South Simcoe's rolling hills. The 5.87 acre property features a pond, stream, pear and apple trees, a detached 2-car garage, and spectacular privacy. The extra-large barn was rebuilt in 2002 by the Mennonites and offers 3 levels of storage, an electrical sub-panel, and water connection from a separate well. Large barn doors make the lower level ideal for horse stalls, animals, tractors, vehicles, or other uses. Enjoy peaceful country living within minutes of Bond Head, Bradford, and Schomberg, with excellent Highway 400 access on 5th Line and close to Bradford GO Station! A rare opportunity to own a distinctive 19th-century home, preserved in its Georgian character and set on a serene country property
Living Room
Hardwood Floor, W/W Fireplace, Wood Trim
4.64 x 4.59 m
Ground
Dining Room
Hardwood Floor, Large Window, Formal Rm
7.11 x 4.47 m
Ground
Library
Hardwood Floor, B/I Bookcase, W/O To Porch
4.59 x 2.15 m
Ground
Family Room
Hardwood Floor, Crown Moulding, Large Window
5.61 x 4.8 m
Ground
Kitchen
Granite Counters, W/W Fireplace, Heated Floor
5.86 x 4.97 m
Ground
Primary Bedroom
Hardwood Floor, Walk-In Closet(s), 3 Pc Ensuite
4.62 x 4.59 m
Second
Bedroom 2
Hardwood Floor, Closet, Wood Trim
4.57 x 3.53 m
Second
Bedroom 3
Hardwood Floor, Large Window, Wood Trim
4.54 x 3.42 m
Second
Bedroom 4
W/O To Balcony, Broadloom
5.46 x 4.97 m
Second
Loft
Window, Hardwood Floor
5.3 x 4.97 m
Second
Interior features
Auto Garage Door Remote, Built-In Oven, Central Vacuum, Countertop Range, Generator - Full, Storage, Sump Pump, Water Heater Owned, Water Purifier, Water Softener
Basement
Separate Entrance, Full, Walk-Up
Bathrooms
1 × 3-piece — Ground, 2 × 3-piece — Second
Fireplace
Yes
Family room
Yes
Kitchens
1
Rooms (above / below grade)
10 above, 0 below
Approximate age
100+
Architectural style
2-Storey
Construction materials
Board & Batten , Brick
Foundation
Stone
Roof
Metal
Exterior features
Landscaped, Patio, Privacy, Porch
Direction faces
South
Garage type
Detached
Garage spaces
2
Total parking spaces
16
Driveway parking
14
Parking features
Private
Lot size
371.63 x 691.96 ft
Lot size area
5.87 Acres
Cross street
5th Line & Highway 27
Directions
5th Line & Highway 27
Neighbourhood
Rural Bradford West Gwillimbury
Heating
Forced Air — Gas
Cooling
Central Air
Water
Sewer
Septic
List price
$2,258,888
Original list price
Annual taxes
$11,856
Tax year
2026
Legal description
PT LT 24 CON 4, (TECUMSETH), PT 3 RD349, EXCEPT PT 3, RD568 ; BRADFORD-WGW
Inclusions
Exclusions
MLS #
N13661380
Status
Active
Transaction type
For Sale
Property type
Residential Freehold
Property sub type
Detached
Days on market
List date
Possession
Flexible
Occupancy
Owner
Listing brokerage
ENGEL & VOLKERS TORONTO CITY
$1,625,000
Median list price
23
Active listings
New in last 30 days
Median days on market
Estimated monthly payment
$10,829
Educational estimate only — actual payment depends on your lender, credit, and insurance requirements.
Sign in to see recent sold prices for homes like this one nearby.

$2,348,000
168 Pine Hill Road, Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON L3Z 0H1
RE/MAX REALTRON REALTY INC.

$2,480,000
245 Pine Hill Road, Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON L3Z 0H1
MASTER`S CHOICE REALTY INC.

$1,899,900
8 Brownlee Drive, Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON L3Z 2A4
COLDWELL BANKER THE REAL ESTATE CENTRE

$2,689,000
102 Pine Hill Road, Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON L3Z 0H1
RE/MAX PREMIER THE OP TEAM

$1,799,900
70 Kilkenny Trail, Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON L3Z 3C5
SOURCE 4 REALTY INC.

$1,795,000
3463 Line 12, Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON L3Z 2A5
ROYAL LEPAGE RCR REALTY